The fundamentals of the political questions: An analysis from constitutional theory and practice

Constitutional practice has coined a doctrine that supposes admitting that there are issues that are exempt from judicial control. Such is the doctrine of the so-called political questions. This type of matter would be excluded from judicial review precisely because of the intrinsically political na...

Descripción completa

Guardado en:
Detalles Bibliográficos
Autor principal: Pedernera Allende, Matías
Formato: Artículo revista
Lenguaje:Español
Publicado: Centro de Investigaciones Jurídicas y Sociales - FD - UNC - CONICET 2022
Materias:
cuestiones políticas
Control judicial
Corte Suprema
supremacía constitucional
Political questions
Judicial review
Supreme Court
Constitutional supremacy
Acceso en línea:https://revistas.unc.edu.ar/index.php/anuariocijs/article/view/37569
Aporte de:
Anuario del Centro de Investigaciones Jurídicas y Sociales de Universidad Nacional de Córdoba
id I10-R282-article-37569
record_format ojs
spelling I10-R282-article-375692022-05-17T20:00:55Z The fundamentals of the political questions: An analysis from constitutional theory and practice Los fundamentos de las "cuestiones políticas no justiciables": Un análisis desde la teoría y la práctica constitucional Pedernera Allende, Matías cuestiones políticas Control judicial Corte Suprema supremacía constitucional Political questions Judicial review Supreme Court Constitutional supremacy Constitutional practice has coined a doctrine that supposes admitting that there are issues that are exempt from judicial control. Such is the doctrine of the so-called political questions. This type of matter would be excluded from judicial review precisely because of the intrinsically political nature of the matters, with respect to which the Judicial Power would not be competent. This doctrine is controversial from various points of view. On the one hand, because its admission could mean a certain “resignation” to constitutional supremacy on certain issues. On the other hand, because in practice it has not been clear how many and what these issues are. At the same time, it is even controversial what is the basis of non-justiciable political issues. In this work, an attempt will be made to identify and systematize the possible foundations that doctrinally and jurisprudence have been offered to support the doctrine of political questions. La práctica constitucional ha acuñado una doctrina que supone admitir que hay cuestiones que se encuentran exentas del control judicial. Tal es la doctrina de la de las llamadas cuestiones políticas no justiciables. Este tipo de materias quedarían excluidas de la revisión judicial precisamente por el carácter intrínsecamente político de los asuntos, respecto de los cuales el Poder Judicial no sería competente. Esta doctrina es controvertida desde diversos puntos de vista. Por un lado, porque su admisión podría significar cierta “renuncia” a la supremacía constitucional en determinados temas. Por otra parte, porque en la práctica no ha sido claro cuantas y cuáles son esas cuestiones. A su vez, incluso, resulta controvertido cuál es el fundamento de las cuestiones políticas no justiciables. En este trabajo, se intentará identificar y sistematizar los posibles fundamentos que doctrinal y jurisprudencialmente se han ofrecido para sostener la doctrina de las cuestiones políticas no justiciables. Centro de Investigaciones Jurídicas y Sociales - FD - UNC - CONICET 2022-05-17 info:eu-repo/semantics/article info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion application/pdf https://revistas.unc.edu.ar/index.php/anuariocijs/article/view/37569 Anuario del Centro de Investigaciones Jurídicas y Sociales; Núm. XX (2022): ANUARIO; 153-167 1667-6122 spa https://revistas.unc.edu.ar/index.php/anuariocijs/article/view/37569/37635 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0
institution Universidad Nacional de Córdoba
institution_str I-10
repository_str R-282
container_title_str Anuario del Centro de Investigaciones Jurídicas y Sociales
language Español
format Artículo revista
topic cuestiones políticas
Control judicial
Corte Suprema
supremacía constitucional
Political questions
Judicial review
Supreme Court
Constitutional supremacy
spellingShingle cuestiones políticas
Control judicial
Corte Suprema
supremacía constitucional
Political questions
Judicial review
Supreme Court
Constitutional supremacy
Pedernera Allende, Matías
The fundamentals of the political questions: An analysis from constitutional theory and practice
topic_facet cuestiones políticas
Control judicial
Corte Suprema
supremacía constitucional
Political questions
Judicial review
Supreme Court
Constitutional supremacy
author Pedernera Allende, Matías
author_facet Pedernera Allende, Matías
author_sort Pedernera Allende, Matías
title The fundamentals of the political questions: An analysis from constitutional theory and practice
title_short The fundamentals of the political questions: An analysis from constitutional theory and practice
title_full The fundamentals of the political questions: An analysis from constitutional theory and practice
title_fullStr The fundamentals of the political questions: An analysis from constitutional theory and practice
title_full_unstemmed The fundamentals of the political questions: An analysis from constitutional theory and practice
title_sort fundamentals of the political questions: an analysis from constitutional theory and practice
description Constitutional practice has coined a doctrine that supposes admitting that there are issues that are exempt from judicial control. Such is the doctrine of the so-called political questions. This type of matter would be excluded from judicial review precisely because of the intrinsically political nature of the matters, with respect to which the Judicial Power would not be competent. This doctrine is controversial from various points of view. On the one hand, because its admission could mean a certain “resignation” to constitutional supremacy on certain issues. On the other hand, because in practice it has not been clear how many and what these issues are. At the same time, it is even controversial what is the basis of non-justiciable political issues. In this work, an attempt will be made to identify and systematize the possible foundations that doctrinally and jurisprudence have been offered to support the doctrine of political questions.
publisher Centro de Investigaciones Jurídicas y Sociales - FD - UNC - CONICET
publishDate 2022
url https://revistas.unc.edu.ar/index.php/anuariocijs/article/view/37569
work_keys_str_mv AT pederneraallendematias thefundamentalsofthepoliticalquestionsananalysisfromconstitutionaltheoryandpractice
AT pederneraallendematias losfundamentosdelascuestionespoliticasnojusticiablesunanalisisdesdelateoriaylapracticaconstitucional
AT pederneraallendematias fundamentalsofthepoliticalquestionsananalysisfromconstitutionaltheoryandpractice
first_indexed 2024-09-03T22:38:42Z
last_indexed 2024-09-03T22:38:42Z
_version_ 1809216304815538176

Ejemplares similares