A critical review of Bronislaw Malinovski’s contributions to legal antropology

Mostrar todas las versiones(2)

This article discusses the contributions of Bronislaw Malinowski regarding the Law in “primitive” populations and their impact in the field of legal anthropology.  The article reviews Malinovski’s analysis of Law, with an emphasis on its role in Functionalism, on its theoretical and methodological i...

Descripción completa

Guardado en:
Detalles Bibliográficos
Autor principal: Quetglas Molina, Augusto Joaquín
Formato: Artículo revista
Lenguaje:Español
Publicado: Facultad de Filosofía y Humanidades. Museo de Antropología 2023
Materias:
Legal anthropology
Bronislaw Malinowski
Functionalism
criticism
reception
Antropología legal
Funcionalismo
Críticas
Recepción
Antropologia jurídica
Análise diacrítica
Recepção
Acceso en línea:https://revistas.unc.edu.ar/index.php/antropologia/article/view/39690
Aporte de:
Revistas de la UNC de Universidad Nacional de Córdoba
id I10-R10-article-39690
record_format ojs
institution Universidad Nacional de Córdoba
institution_str I-10
repository_str R-10
container_title_str Revistas de la UNC
language Español
format Artículo revista
topic Legal anthropology
Bronislaw Malinowski
Functionalism
criticism
reception
Antropología legal
Bronislaw Malinowski
Funcionalismo
Críticas
Recepción
Antropologia jurídica
Bronislaw Malinowski
Funcionalismo
Análise diacrítica
Recepção
spellingShingle Legal anthropology
Bronislaw Malinowski
Functionalism
criticism
reception
Antropología legal
Bronislaw Malinowski
Funcionalismo
Críticas
Recepción
Antropologia jurídica
Bronislaw Malinowski
Funcionalismo
Análise diacrítica
Recepção
Quetglas Molina, Augusto Joaquín
A critical review of Bronislaw Malinovski’s contributions to legal antropology
topic_facet Legal anthropology
Bronislaw Malinowski
Functionalism
criticism
reception
Antropología legal
Bronislaw Malinowski
Funcionalismo
Críticas
Recepción
Antropologia jurídica
Bronislaw Malinowski
Funcionalismo
Análise diacrítica
Recepção
author Quetglas Molina, Augusto Joaquín
author_facet Quetglas Molina, Augusto Joaquín
author_sort Quetglas Molina, Augusto Joaquín
title A critical review of Bronislaw Malinovski’s contributions to legal antropology
title_short A critical review of Bronislaw Malinovski’s contributions to legal antropology
title_full A critical review of Bronislaw Malinovski’s contributions to legal antropology
title_fullStr A critical review of Bronislaw Malinovski’s contributions to legal antropology
title_full_unstemmed A critical review of Bronislaw Malinovski’s contributions to legal antropology
title_sort critical review of bronislaw malinovski’s contributions to legal antropology
description This article discusses the contributions of Bronislaw Malinowski regarding the Law in “primitive” populations and their impact in the field of legal anthropology.  The article reviews Malinovski’s analysis of Law, with an emphasis on its role in Functionalism, on its theoretical and methodological innovations from previous work in the area, and on some of Malinovski’s concepts which were subjects of discussion in the field. The objections found in the literature regarding Malinovski’s legal anthropology approach are discussed by focusing on four types of critics: (i) those that reject the extension given to the concept of Law, (ii) those that question the appropriateness of separating  Civil and Criminal law, (iii) those that point to the excessive rationality that Malinovski attributed to “primitive” populations, and (iv) the multiple objections made to the lack of coherence and continuity of Malinovski’s definitions along his works.
publisher Facultad de Filosofía y Humanidades. Museo de Antropología
publishDate 2023
url https://revistas.unc.edu.ar/index.php/antropologia/article/view/39690
work_keys_str_mv AT quetglasmolinaaugustojoaquin acriticalreviewofbronislawmalinovskiscontributionstolegalantropology
AT quetglasmolinaaugustojoaquin balancecriticodelaantropologialegaldebronislawmalinowski
AT quetglasmolinaaugustojoaquin umaavaliacaocriticadaantropologiajuridicadebronislawmalinowski
AT quetglasmolinaaugustojoaquin criticalreviewofbronislawmalinovskiscontributionstolegalantropology
first_indexed 2023-05-25T23:50:51Z
last_indexed 2023-05-25T23:50:51Z
_version_ 1770717908468498432
spelling I10-R10-article-396902023-04-28T18:01:52Z A critical review of Bronislaw Malinovski’s contributions to legal antropology Balance crítico de la antropología legal de Bronislaw Malinowski Uma avaliação crítica da antropologia jurídica de Bronislaw Malinowski Quetglas Molina, Augusto Joaquín Legal anthropology Bronislaw Malinowski Functionalism criticism reception Antropología legal Bronislaw Malinowski Funcionalismo Críticas Recepción Antropologia jurídica Bronislaw Malinowski Funcionalismo Análise diacrítica Recepção This article discusses the contributions of Bronislaw Malinowski regarding the Law in “primitive” populations and their impact in the field of legal anthropology.  The article reviews Malinovski’s analysis of Law, with an emphasis on its role in Functionalism, on its theoretical and methodological innovations from previous work in the area, and on some of Malinovski’s concepts which were subjects of discussion in the field. The objections found in the literature regarding Malinovski’s legal anthropology approach are discussed by focusing on four types of critics: (i) those that reject the extension given to the concept of Law, (ii) those that question the appropriateness of separating  Civil and Criminal law, (iii) those that point to the excessive rationality that Malinovski attributed to “primitive” populations, and (iv) the multiple objections made to the lack of coherence and continuity of Malinovski’s definitions along his works. El artículo recorre la producción intelectual de Bronislaw Malinowski sobre la ley en los pueblos “primitivos”, atendiendo principalmente a la recepción de su trabajo en el campo de la antropología legal. Revisamos el análisis malinowskiano del derecho, destacando el lugar que éste ocupa dentro de la teoría funcionalista, las innovaciones teóricas y metodológicas que presenta respecto a los antecedentes en la materia, y algunos conceptos particulares que fueron posteriormente objeto de debate. Reunimos luego las objeciones más frecuentes a la antropología legal de Malinowski dentro de la literatura específica, examinando cuatro tipos de críticas: primero, aquellas que atacan la extensión dada al concepto de ley; segundo, las que se dirigen a cuestionar la pertinencia de la distinción entre derecho civil y criminal; tercero, las que señalan la hipertrofia racional que Malinowski creía encontrar en los nativos; y por último, las múltiples objeciones a la coherencia y continuidad de las definiciones de Malinowski a lo largo de sus escritos. Este artigo analisa a produção intelectual de Bronislaw Malinowski sobre o direito entre os povos "primitivos", concentrando-se principalmente na recepção de seu trabalho no campo da antropologia jurídica. Revisamos a análise malinowskiana do direito, destacando seu lugar dentro da teoria funcionalista, as inovações teóricas e metodológicas que apresenta com relação aos precedentes no campo e alguns conceitos específicos que foram posteriormente objeto de debate. Em seguida, reunimos as objeções mais frequentes à antropologia jurídica de Malinowski na literatura específica, examinando quatro tipos de críticas: primeiro, as que atacam a extensão dada ao conceito de lei; segundo, as que visam questionar a relevância da distinção entre lei civil e lei penal; terceiro, as que apontam para a hipertrofia racional que Malinowski acreditava ter encontrado nos nativos; e, finalmente, as múltiplas objeções à coerência e à continuidade das definições de Malinowski ao longo de seus escritos. Facultad de Filosofía y Humanidades. Museo de Antropología 2023-04-28 info:eu-repo/semantics/article info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion Peer reviewed article Artículo revisado por pares Artigo revisado por pares application/pdf https://revistas.unc.edu.ar/index.php/antropologia/article/view/39690 Revista del Museo de Antropología; Vol 16 (2023) ISSUE 1; 127-138 Revista del Museo de Antropología; Vol 16 (2023) NÚMERO 1; 127-138 Revista del Museo de Antropología; Vol 16 (2023) NÚMERO 1; 127-138 1852-4826 1852-060X 10.31048/1852.4826.v16.n1 spa https://revistas.unc.edu.ar/index.php/antropologia/article/view/39690/41136 Derechos de autor 2023 Augusto Joaquín Quetglas Molina https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0

Ejemplares similares